Productivity · Professionals · Stable
Difficulty in achieving visual clarity in data presentation due to conflicting design principles
Users struggle to balance the amount of non-data ink and visual clarity in bar charts, leading to confusion in effective data representation.
Who experiences it: Data analysts and designers
Momentum
0%
Pain
75
Competition
90
Opportunity
60/100
Signals over time
4 observed signals across 1 sources, tracked for 48 days. Confidence: low.
What people are saying Observed
“If you only take that idea in one direction then I agree that it is pretty silly. However, the spirit of the visualization suggests finding a balance and optimizing the data-ink ratio rather than searching for a perfect value. If you follow the link you'll find the article I wrote talking about this: https://scienceux.org/articles/data-ink-ideal-vs-minimal All the points that you make are very much valid, and it is good that you have pointed these things out because I wouldn't want people to follow these principles blindly without thinking about it for themselves. I haven't considered the 'ratio of integral of norm of gradient of colour' too much (because it is easier to start simple and build on it), but I hope you might consider elaborating on it.”
Hacker News · request
“Narrowing the bars is not reducing non-data ink ratio imo and against the spirit. The bars are the data. And they therefore should be maximally visible, the same way that you BOLD text (make it thicker) that you want to emphasize rather than thin it to "reduce non-message ink ratio." For the width of the bar there is practically speaking a middle ground that uses thick bars but not too thick/close together such that it harms legibility.”
Hacker News · frustration
“I think the idea that a bar chart is usually improved by narrowing its bars while keeping them in the same positions is pretty silly. Yes, the article does say that one can take it too far, but I think that's the wrong framing. It's not that using less ink is good, but sometimes if you take that too far then it competes with visual clarity . Visual clarity is always the goal; sometimes clearer designs have more non-data ink, sometimes less; many designs are too busy so "less non-data ink" is usually good, but not always. Tufte's "data-ink ratio" is a pretty good heuristic, but e.g. it would probably become a better match for actual visual clarity if what you counted wasn't "amount of ink" but something that measures spatial change in ink. It's the transitions that feel like noise, much more than patches of constant colour. But "data-ink ratio" is easier to say and easier to read than "ratio of integral of norm of gradient of colour". Also, I think this sort of graph is better with very light gridlines than with no gridlines, though I think Tufte would disagree. Also also, in Tufte's book, immediately be”
Hacker News · complaint
“I think the idea that a bar chart is usually improved by narrowing its bars while keeping them in the same positions is pretty silly. Yes, the article does say that one can take it too far, but I think that's the wrong framing. It's not that using less ink is good, but sometimes if you take that too far then it competes with visual clarity . Visual clarity is always the goal; sometimes clearer designs have more non-data ink, sometimes less; many designs are too busy so "less non-data ink" is usually good, but not always. Tufte's "data-ink ratio" is a pretty good heuristic, but e.g. it would probably become a better match for actual visual clarity if what you counted wasn't "amount of ink" but something that measures spatial change in ink. It's the transitions that feel like noise, much more than patches of constant colour. But "data-ink ratio" is easier to say and easier to read than "ratio of integral of norm of gradient of colour". Also, I think this sort of graph is better with very light gridlines than with no gridlines, though I think Tufte would disagree. Also also, in Tufte's book, immediately be”
Hacker News · complaint
Why now? AI inference
Existing solutions Observed
- Tableau · $70/user/mo · complaints: High cost for small teams, Steep learning curve for advanced features, Performance issues with large datasets
- Google Data Studio · Free Free · complaints: Limited functionality compared to paid tools, Occasional bugs and glitches, Less flexibility in design customization
- Qlik Sense · $30/user/mo · complaints: High learning curve for new users, Expensive for larger teams, Limited support for certain data sources
- Microsoft Power BI · $9.99/user/mo · complaints: Limited customization options for visuals, Occasional performance lags, Complexity in sharing reports
- Looker · Standard Contact sales · complaints: High cost for small businesses, Complex setup process, Steep learning curve for new users
There is a gap in the market for a data visualization tool that effectively balances the needs of data analysts and designers, providing both robust functionality and ease of use without the high costs associated with existing solutions. Current offerings, while strong in certain areas, often present challenges such as steep learning curves, limited customization, and performance issues, particularly for small teams.
See the full evidence, competitor gap matrix and opportunity report.
Free account. No credit card.