AI · Professionals · Stable
Struggling to understand the evolving role of humans in the software engineering industry due to AI disruption
The narrative around AI focuses heavily on tools and capabilities, leaving a gap in understanding the human impact and roles in the industry.
Who experiences it: Software engineers and professionals in the tech industry.
Momentum
0%
Pain
75
Competition
90
Opportunity
64/100
Signals over time
6 observed signals across 1 sources, tracked for 48 days. Confidence: medium.
What people are saying Observed
“I have been asking LLMs to review/edit prompts since GPT4o era, so I really don't know what the point of this snarky comment is. Since GPT4o, I have been convinced that most of the digital work would be done by AI and humans' job is to "move the chairs around to not block AI's way." It's a given to me. I'm just debating whether reading the code makes me a better chair-remover.”
Hacker News · frustration
“As you note, some aspects of the work may largely go away. Like writing in machine code did, once we got assemblers. Like writing in assembly did once we got compilers. We still do some of those things, in rare cases. But for most people, we don’t do them anymore. We use other tools to do them. But at some point, I think the job changes enough that I question if we can still be called software engineers? Unlike previous tools, where we were using them directly by writing code or instructions in languages that are not native for humans to speak, now we are using human languages to direct what we want from AI. I actually did this at my previous job, which you can see in my LinkedIn profile. If we are using AI to write our code for us based on our specifications that are written in a natural human language, then I submit that we are becoming something more like directors or conductors of software engineering. We’re not doing the job directly anymore, and we’re not managing other people to do the job directly, so I don’t know if we can call ourselves software engineers anymore. Nor do I think we should call ourselves software managers, because we are not managing people doing the work.”
Hacker News · frustration
“I'm taking a bit of a risk with this one, this is a novella I authored with the help of AI. If that offends you, please move on! Everyone on HN knows just how much AI is disrupting our industry. Although, much of the industry narrative focusses on the tools, the AI, the harnesses, and their ever-growing capabilities. We need to spend just as much, if not more time discussing the impact this is having on us. Humans will still be a significant part of the software engineering ‘system’, and many of us are rapidly trying to determine what our role will ultimately be. Storytelling is a great medium for communicating and understanding change. That’s why I really enjoy books like The Phoenix Project — a vehicle for helping people understand the DevOps transformation from a human perspective. This story is very much inspired by The Phoenix Project: a near-future account of the impact AI has on an organisation deep in the pursuit of speed, ignoring the risks and the human impact. This story was written with the help of AI. While I can write a decent technical blog post, there is no hope for me when it comes to works of fiction! I have not tried to disguise the AI writing, and I have no”
Hacker News · frustration
“I'm taking a bit of a risk with this one, this is a novella I authored with the help of AI. If that offends you, please move on! Everyone on HN knows just how much AI is disrupting our industry. Although, much of the industry narrative focusses on the tools, the AI, the harnesses, and their ever-growing capabilities. We need to spend just as much, if not more time discussing the impact this is having on us. Humans will still be a significant part of the software engineering ‘system’, and many of us are rapidly trying to determine what our role will ultimately be. Storytelling is a great medium for communicating and understanding change. That’s why I really enjoy books like The Phoenix Project — a vehicle for helping people understand the DevOps transformation from a human perspective. This story is very much inspired by The Phoenix Project: a near-future account of the impact AI has on an organisation deep in the pursuit of speed, ignoring the risks and the human impact. This story was written with the help of AI. While I can write a decent technical blog post, there is no hope for me when it comes to works of fiction! I have not tried to disguise the AI writing, and I have no”
Hacker News · frustration
“I'm taking a bit of a risk with this one, this is a novella I authored with the help of AI. If that offends you, please move on! Everyone on HN knows just how much AI is disrupting our industry. Although, much of the industry narrative focusses on the tools, the AI, the harnesses, and their ever-growing capabilities. We need to spend just as much, if not more time discussing the impact this is having on us. Humans will still be a significant part of the software engineering ‘system’, and many of us are rapidly trying to determine what our role will ultimately be. Storytelling is a great medium for communicating and understanding change. That’s why I really enjoy books like The Phoenix Project — a vehicle for helping people understand the DevOps transformation from a human perspective. This story is very much inspired by The Phoenix Project: a near-future account of the impact AI has on an organisation deep in the pursuit of speed, ignoring the risks and the human impact. This story was written with the help of AI. While I can write a decent technical blog post, there is no hope for me when it comes to works of fiction! I have not tried to disguise the AI writing, and I have no”
Hacker News · frustration
Why now? AI inference
Existing solutions Observed
- Udacity · $399/mo for Nanodegree programs · complaints: High cost for some users, Limited course offerings compared to competitors, Some projects may be overly challenging
- Coursera · Coursera Plus Contact us · Coursera for Teams Contact us · complaints: Quality of courses can vary, Limited interaction with instructors, Some courses may be too basic
- LinkedIn Learning · $29.99/mo or $239.88/yr · complaints: Content can be too basic for advanced users, Limited depth in some subjects, Subscription model may not suit everyone
- Pluralsight · For teams 2 - 20 $399/month per user, billed annually · complaints: Some courses may be outdated, User interface can be confusing, Higher cost compared to some alternatives
- edX · Artificial Intelligence Programme $75 · complaints: Some courses can be too theoretical, Limited interaction with peers, Certificate costs can add up
There is a lack of affordable, comprehensive educational resources specifically addressing the evolving role of humans in software engineering amidst AI disruption. Current offerings from competitors focus on general skills and knowledge but do not adequately prepare professionals for the unique challenges and changes brought about by AI in the tech industry.
See the full evidence, competitor gap matrix and opportunity report.
Free account. No credit card.